New Prospect Heights Spot Joins NYC's Dwindling Wood-Oven Restaurants Chef Akhtar Nawab and restaurateur Michael Wetherbee, the team behind Alta Calidad, have opened ayayay… at 554 Vanderbilt Avenue in Brooklyn's Prospect Heights neighborhood. The 39-seat bar and oven concept occupies the former Wayward Fare space and distinguishes itself by housing one of New York City's few remaining wood-burning brick ovens.
The Menu: European Comfort Food With Playful Twists Drawing from three decades in New York kitchens including Gramercy Tavern, Craft, and Craftbar, Nawab built a menu around European-inspired comfort food layered with unexpected flavors. The signature ayayay… Butter Burger and Fries and Steak 'n Eggs Toast with salmoriglio anchor the larger plates. Smaller shareable dishes range from Duck Fat and Smoked Butter Popcorn and Curried Marcona Almonds to Georgian Cheesy Bread with mushrooms and a quail egg and Spicy Lamb Sausage-Stuffed Pappadew Peppers. Desserts include Lemon Madeleines and Chef Pablo's ice cream and sorbet.
Beverage Program Emphasizes Accessibility Wetherbee oversees a wine list spanning Italy, France, Germany, Portugal, and California, with selections priced between $14–$24 per glass across sparkling, white, skin-contact, rosé, and red offerings. The cocktail menu features six classics alongside signatures like the Olive Branch Martini, made with vodka, gin, Cocchi, and olive oil, and a customizable Martini Your Way. Beer selections include IPAs, pilsners, and lagers, while non-alcoholic options feature N/A Prosecco and a house-made Rosé Limonada made with Seedlip, ginger, lime, rose liqueur, and non-alcoholic sparkling wine.
Design Details Designer Martina Guandalini drew inspiration from traditional European wine bars for the intimate nine-seat bar and 30-dining-seat space. Walnut wood wainscoting, olive-green banquettes, cream ceramic tiles, and a black-and-white patterned linoleum floor create nostalgic atmosphere, with a metallic plaster bar providing contemporary contrast. A hand-painted mural by Mexican-born, Brooklyn-based artist Fernanda Uribe adorns the wood-burning brick oven's feature wall, complemented by handmade circular tiles.
Hours and Reservations Service runs Monday–Thursday, 5–11 p.m.; Friday–Saturday, 5 p.m.–midnight.
Sunday is closed. Reservations are available via Resy.
Why It Matters
The restaurant taps into the ongoing demand for approachable neighborhood bars with distinctive culinary identity in high-traffic Brooklyn locations, while adding to a shrinking pool of NYC establishments operating traditional wood-fired ovens.
For more insights and trends in the food and beverage sector, check out more articles in The Food & Beverage Magazine family of publications.
Written by FBM Publications Editors